| Rnd | Team | Match Date | Home Team | Result | Away Team |
|---|
| 3 | First XI | 1958-11-01 | Murrumbeena |  | Olympic |
| 9/239 D Kivell 82 A Schrape 43 W Driver 44
and 5/90 R McDermott 40* | | 9/111 F Jungwirth 4/33 |
| 5 | First XI | 1958-11-29 | Murrumbeena | | Glenhuntly |
| 6/215 W Driver 70 D Johnston 52 J McDermott 51* | | 143 W Driver 3/18 F Jungwirth 3/21 |
| 8 | First XI | 1959-01-24 | Bentleigh | | Murrumbeena |
| 74 F Jungwirth 5/17
and 101 D Johnston 6/21(inc double hat-trick) | | 169 G Browne 58 D Kivell 34
and 0/10 |
| SF | First XI | 1959-03-07 | Carnegie | def | Murrumbeena |
| 62 A Schrape 7/21
and 90 F Jungwirth 4/37 | | 9/38
and 1/37 |
