| Season | Rnd | Match Date | Home Team | Result | Away Team |
|---|
| 1993-94 | 3 | 1993-10-30 | Elsternwick | tied | Murrumbeena |
| 188 C Rule 3/65 S Goold 3/34 J Dennis 2/30 | | 188 A Trevethan 110* |
| 1992-93 | 3 | 1992-10-24 | Murrumbeena | no play | Elsternwick |
| 1991-92 | 6 | 1991-12-14 | Murrumbeena |  | Elsternwick |
| 180 S Avery 28 M Rice 31 | | 177 R Breddy 4/27 D Wilkinson 3/72 |
| 1990-91 | 8 | 1991-01-12 | Elsternwick | | Murrumbeena |
| 8/245 B Carbone 3/66 J Dennis 4/30 | | 9/374 D Evans 43 D McDermott 112 B Carbone 116* |
| 1989-90 | 9 | 1990-01-27 | Elsternwick | drew | Murrumbeena |
| | | 8/275 G Stogiannidis 148 J Bailes 54 |
| 1984-85 | 6 | 1984-12-22 | Elsternwick | | Murrumbeena |
| 8/92 G Burns 2/44 A Paton 3/30 | | 4/167 J McDermott 73* I Walker 48 |
| 1977-78 | 9 | 1978-01-14 | Murrumbeena | lost to | Elsternwick |
| 129 P Murr 63 | | 8/132 P White 3/41 J Dennis 2/43 P Murr 3/15 |
| 1973-74 | 9 | 1974-01-28 | Murrumbeena | | Elsternwick |
| 85 PS Newton 38 | | 81 S Goold 4/31 D Wilkinson 4/40 |
| 1956-57 | 10 | 1957-02-09 | Murrumbeena ^ | | Elsternwick |
| 267 J McAlister 87 F Jungwirth 80 | | 90 F Jungwirth 5/27
and 146 F Jungwirth 3/51 |
