| Rnd | Team | Match Date | Home Team | Result | Away Team |
|---|
| 3 | Third XI | 1958-11-01 | East Malvern |  | Murrumbeena |
| 54 M Hardham 4/20 W Butler 4/33
and 89 M Hardham 4/25 W Butler 2/21 V Rodwell 2/13 | | 63
and 87 M Hardham 41 |
| 6 | Third XI | 1958-12-13 | Murrumbeena | lost to | Myrall |
| 80 B Chalk 26
and 93 J McAlister 28 | | 131 W Butler 4/38 |
| 7 | Third XI | 1959-01-10 | East Malvern | def | Murrumbeena |
| 8/141 J McAlister 2/24 D Fotheringham 2/31 W Butler 2/29 | | 136 M Hardham 47 J McAlister 28
and 3/59 D Griffiths 40 |
| 9 | Third XI | 1959-01-26 | Caulfield | | Murrumbeena |
| 51 M Hardham 5/21 W Butler 5/20 | | 107 J McAlister 26 |
| 10 | Third XI | 1959-02-07 | Murrumbeena | | Seddon |
| 166 J McAlister 52 D Fotheringham 29 | | 103 W Butler 4/35
and 2/60 |
