| Rnd | Team | Match Date | Home Team | Result | Away Team |
|---|
| 4 | Fourth XI | 1958-11-15 | Ormond | def | Murrumbeena |
| 112 J Macwhirter 2/19 R Johnston 7/58
and 2/61 | | 92 Jack Hindmarsh 27*
and 79 |
| 5 | Fourth XI | 1958-11-29 | Murrumbeena |  | Elsternwick |
| 250 E Watson 80 N Harbour 43 K Watson 37 | | 70 E Watson 7/51
and 111 D Barnett 5/19 |
| 6 | Fourth XI | 1958-12-13 | Murrumbeena | lost to | Carnegie |
| 74
and 4/97 E Watson 50 | | 7/123 R Johnston 3/53 |
| 9 | Fourth XI | 1959-01-26 | Murrumbeena | lost to | Hampton |
| 96 E Watson 42 A MacGregor 29 | | 119 Jack Hindmarsh 2/8 W Singleton 3/28 N Harbour 3/39 J Launder 2/28
and 5/57 W Coghill 2/6 |
