| Rnd | Team | Match Date | Home Team | Result | Away Team |
|---|
| 2 | Fifth XI | 1995-10-14 | Mt Waverley Uniting |  | Murrumbeena |
| 5/104 G Scott 2/4 | | 8/150 A Price 47N J Bailes 26 |
| 2 | Fourth XI | 1995-10-21 | Mentone | def | Murrumbeena |
| 9/315 A Loughron 2/82 S Gifford 4/56 R Scott 2/44 | | 185 A Loughron 27 D Healy 31 S Gifford 85*
and 1/21 |
| 3 | Fourth XI | 1995-11-04 | Murrumbeena | lost to | McKinnon |
| 117 K O'Halloran 77
and 5/66 K O'Halloran 36* | | 283 R Paton 2/35 S Gifford 3/71 |
| 4 | Fourth XI | 1995-11-18 | Old Mentonians | def | Murrumbeena |
| 9/170 S Gifford 3/19 R Paton 5/26 | | 164 J Bailes 47 N Jamieson 51* |
| 5 | Fourth XI | 1995-12-02 | Hampton | def | Murrumbeena |
| 245 R Breddy 5/71 A Loughron 3/71 | | 236 D Evans 116 T Jenkinson 28 J Gray 35* |
| 13 | Fifth XI | 1996-01-27 | St Johns Elsternwick | | Murrumbeena |
| 8/128 J Hancock 3/10 J Gange 3/26 B Gillespie 2/16 | | 7/180 S Hancock 50N M McRae 33 |
| 14 | Fifth XI | 1996-02-03 | Emerald Hill | def | Murrumbeena |
| 5/130 B Gillespie 2/26 | | 128 |
| 15 | Fifth XI | 1996-02-10 | Murrumbeena | | Carnegie United |
| 4/157 C Way 48* S Hancock 38 M McRae 25 | | 7/132 S Hancock 2/19 N Jamieson 2/25 |
| 16 | Fifth XI | 1996-02-17 | Murrumbeena | lost to | Mt Waverley Catholics |
| 9/180 D Anderson 41 J Gange 34 N Jamieson 25 T Sekker 30 | | 7/200 B Gillespie 3/51 J Gange 3/24 |
| 17 | Fifth XI | 1996-02-24 | Murrumbeena | lost to | Mt Waverley Uniting |
| 9/195 C Way 27 S Hancock 29 T Sekker 44* | | 5/271 J Vardy 2/22 |
| 18 | Fifth XI | 1996-03-02 | Monash University | | Murrumbeena |
| 8/127 N Jamieson 3/23 B Gillespie 2/18 | | 4/133 J Hancock 38N C Way 32 B Day 37* |
| SF | Fifth XI | 1996-03-09 | Murrumbeena ^ | | Burwood Summerhill |
| 8/170 J Hancock 41 S Hancock 45 B Day 26 | | 136 S Hancock 3/44 N Jamieson 3/37 |
| GF | Fifth XI | 1996-03-16 | Murrumbeena ^ | lost to | Mt Waverley Uniting |
| 86 J Hancock 34 | | 103 J Gange 5/22 B Gillespie 2/15 |
